top of page
Writer's pictureJason Bailey

Why Sharing Fishing Charters in Cabo Can Be a Bad Idea

Updated: Aug 4

Booking a Cabo San Lucas fishing charter is often seen as the pinnacle of an angler's dream: an opportunity to head out on a well-equipped boat with a knowledgeable captain, targeting prized fish in prime locations. While the idea of sharing fishing charters in Cabo with strangers might seem like a way to cut costs and make new friends, it can sometimes turn into a less-than-ideal experience. Here are several reasons why sharing a private fishing charter with strangers can be a bad idea.


1. Divergent Goals and Expectations


Fishing trips mean different things to different people. Some may be looking for a peaceful day on the water, enjoying the tranquility and the process of fishing itself. Others might be adrenaline junkies eager for the thrill of landing the biggest catch. When you share a charter with strangers, the chances are high that their goals and expectations will not align with yours. This mismatch can lead to frustration and disappointment for all parties involved.


2. Varying Skill Levels


Fishing with strangers means encountering a wide range of skill levels. An experienced angler might find their patience tested by a novice who requires constant guidance and makes frequent mistakes. Conversely, a novice might feel overwhelmed and embarrassed, which can ruin the enjoyment of the trip. Balancing the needs and expectations of everyone can be challenging, detracting from the overall experience.


3. Personality Clashes


Spending up to eight hours in close quarters with people you've never met before can be risky. Personality clashes are almost inevitable in such situations. Differences in communication styles, attitudes, and behaviors can lead to tension and conflict. What starts as an exciting adventure can quickly turn into an uncomfortable situation if you and your boatmates don't get along. They may cuss and you don't, they may drink or smoke and you don't...the list goes on and on.


4. Lack of Personalized Experience


One of the main benefits of booking a private fishing charter is the personalized experience. The captain and crew can tailor the trip to your preferences, whether that means targeting specific fish, exploring particular spots, or offering specific guidance and support. When sharing the charter with strangers, this personalized attention is diluted. The captain must try to accommodate everyone's preferences, often resulting in a more generic experience that might not meet anyone's expectations fully.


5. Financial Disputes


While sharing a charter can reduce costs, it can also lead to financial disputes. Issues such as tipping the crew, can sour the trip and create lasting negative impressions. This aside from if the other party does not show up, which happens, leaving you with a larger cost for their "share" of the charter than you had planned on.


6. Who Goes First


Here's the scenario... Your dream has always been to fish in Cabo and catch a marlin. As it turns out, this is also the dream of your boatmates. How do you decide who catches the first fish...or subsequent fish? What if only two fish are caught, and you are with three other strangers? These same situations have happened on shared charters more times than you can imagine.


7. Privacy and Security Concerns


Sharing a private charter with strangers means entrusting your personal belongings and safety to people you don't know. There’s always a risk, albeit small, of theft or damage to your property. Furthermore, any disagreement or conflict could potentially escalate, leading to an uncomfortable and unsafe situation far from shore.


8. Seasickness


You may be perfectly fine on the water, but your boatmates on a shared charter may not. If one or more gets seasick, you now have a difficult situation to navigate, such as whether you agree to go in early for their benefit, cutting your trip short, and as to how you may or may not be compensated by them for an early return when you may have several hours or more of charter time remaining.


Conclusion


While sharing a private fishing charter with strangers can seem like a cost-effective way to enjoy a fishing trip, the potential downsides often outweigh the benefits. From divergent goals and limited space to personality clashes and financial disputes, the experience can quickly become less enjoyable. For a truly memorable and satisfying fishing adventure, consider either booking a private charter for yourself and your chosen companions or joining a group where you can be sure of a more compatible and harmonious experience.


4 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page